As a self-proclaimed pizza lover and St. Catharines local, I've spent plenty of time exploring the city's pizza scene in search of the best slice.
From classic pepperoni to creative toppings, St. Catharines has no shortage of delicious pizza options to choose from.
Over the years, I've visited numerous pizza joints and tasted my way through their menus, noting the standout dishes and unique features of each place.
In this guide, I'll share my personal reviews and insights into some of the best pizza joints in St. Catharines, giving you a foodie's perspective on where to go and what to expect.
Whether you're a first-time visitor or a long-time resident, I hope this guide will inspire you to go out and find your own favorite pizza spot in St. Catharines.
Best Pizza in St Catharines
1. St. Catharines Pizza Company
Located in the heart of St. Catharines, St. Catharines Pizza Company is a cozy little spot with a great atmosphere. The menu has a wide variety of pizza options, and the quality of the ingredients is evident in every bite.
Their wood-fired oven pizzas are definitely a standout, with crispy crusts and delicious toppings. The garlic knots are also a must-try, with a perfect balance of garlic and butter.
The staff is friendly and attentive, making for an overall enjoyable experience. One downside is that parking can be a bit of a challenge in the area, but it's well worth it for the delicious pizza
- Address: 224 Lakeport Rd, St. Catharines, ON L2N 4R5, Canada
- Website: http://stcatharinespizzaco.com/
- Phone Number: +19059350808
- Working Hours: 11:00 AM- 12:00 PM
- Directions: St. Catharines Pizza Company
2. Pie Guys Tap And Grill
Pie Guys Tap And Grill is a casual pizza joint with a great selection of craft beers and other drinks. The pizzas are creative and delicious, with unique toppings like mac and cheese and buffalo chicken.
The garlic bread is also a standout, with a perfect balance of garlic and cheese. The atmosphere is lively and fun, making it a great spot for a night out with friends.
One downside is that the service can be a bit slow during peak times, but it's worth the wait for the delicious pizza and drinks.
- Address: 10 Mac Turnbull Dr, St. Catharines, ON L2S 3W5, Canada
- Website: http://pieguyspizzeria.ca/
- Phone Number: +12893622221/ ext 2
- Working Hours: 12:00 AM- 10:00/ 11:00 PM
- Directions: Pie Guys Tap And Grill
3. Rollin' Pizza - Handcrafted Pizza + Pasta
Rollin' Pizza is a food truck that can be found at various locations around St. Catharines. Their pizzas are made to order and cooked on the spot, ensuring maximum freshness and flavor.
The classic pepperoni pizza is a standout, with a crispy crust and just the right amount of toppings. The staff is friendly and welcoming, making for a great overall experience.
One downside is that the hours and locations of the food truck can be a bit unpredictable, so it's important to check their social media pages for updates.
- Address: 314 Lake St, St. Catharines, ON L2N 4H4, Canada
- Website: https://www.rollinpizza.ca/
- Phone Number: +19059389797
- Working Hours: 12:00- 9:00 PM/ Weekend 3:00 - 9:00
- Directions: Rollin' Pizza - Handcrafted Pizza + Pasta
4. Paesano Pizza
Paesano Pizza is a family-owned pizzeria with a cozy atmosphere and friendly staff. The pizzas are classic and delicious, with a perfect balance of sauce and toppings.
The garlic knots are also a must-try, with a perfect balance of garlic and butter. The staff is attentive and welcoming, making for a great overall experience.
One downside is that the parking lot can be quite small and busy during peak times, but it's worth it for the delicious pizza.
- Address: 595 Carlton St, St. Catharines, ON L2M 4Y2, Canada
- Website: http://www.paesanopizza.net/
- Phone Number: +19059355454
- Working Hours: 11:00 AM- 9:00 / 10:00 PM
- Directions: Paesano Pizza
5. Pete's Pizza
Pete's Pizza is a classic pizza joint with a great selection of toppings and sides. The pizzas are well-made and flavorful, with a crispy crust and generous toppings.
The garlic bread is also a standout, with a perfect balance of garlic and cheese. The staff is friendly and accommodating, making for a great overall experience.
One downside is that the restaurant can get quite busy during peak times, so it's important to come prepared for a wait. Their specialty is their wide range of unique and delicious pizza toppings.
- Address: 286 Bunting Rd, St. Catharines, ON L2M 7M2, Canada
- Website: http://www.petespizzaniagara.ca/
- Phone Number: +19056881234
- Working Hours: 11:00- 10:00 PM -Weekend 11-00 AM 11:00 PM
- Directions: Pete's Pizza
St. Catharines has some great pizza joints to choose from, each with their own unique atmosphere and menu.
Whether you're in the mood for classic pizza or something more creative, there's something for everyone.
While each place has its own pros and cons, they all offer delicious pizza and a great overall experience.
