Top 7 Italian Restaurants in Hamilton (Reviewed By a Local)

Italian Restaurants in Hamilton

Hamilton has a wide variety of Italian cuisine, including authentic Neapolitan pizza, fresh, and restaurants serving fresh made pasta.

Hamilton’s abundance of Italian restaurants might be a little overwhelming, but in the nicest manner possible. Italian cuisine comes in a vast range, which Hamilton is fortunate to have.

You’ll find everything from family-run food trucks to quaint terraces with a view of the city to mouthwatering red sauce.

I’ve compiled a list of ten best Italian restaurants in Hamilton, each with its distinct flavor and level of brilliance. I hope this list helps you find the most outstanding Italian restaurant for your needs, whether you’re looking for pasta and pizza or something different.

You will definitely discover a choice you like, and I know you will appreciate visiting one (or more) of these top-notch places.

The Best Italian Restaurants in Hamilton

La Spaghett Pasta House


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by La Spaghett (@laspaghett)

Looking for a place to celebrate a special occasion, or just have a quiet dinner with that special someone? Come dine at La Spaghett!

They have been serving up fresh pasta dishes with artisan sauces since 1999, they use only the freshest ingredients prepared in house daily using old world recipes.

Whether you’re celebrating a birthday, anniversary or treating your family to some great Italian food.

Address: 970 Upper James St, Hamilton, ON L9C 3A5, Canada


Phone: +19053188211

Giuseppe's Italian Cuisine & Pizza


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by vuis_plate (@vuis_plate)

If you're looking for delicious Italian cuisine in a casual and laid-back atmosphere, look no further than Giuseppe's Pizza.

Their menu features many favorites like lasagna and spaghetti, alongside some more unique offerings like cannolis (a sweet pastry filled with cream) and mozzarella sticks.

Address: 762 King St E, Hamilton, ON L8M 1A5, Canada


Phone: +19055253334

Born & Raised

Inspired by bold and vibrant Italian flavours, Born & Raised is a fresh new approach to dining in the heart of Hamilton.

Their unique menu takes the best of Ontario and Italy, spinning it into seasonal dishes that will light up your taste buds.

Address: 224 James St N, Hamilton, ON L8R 2L3, Canada


Phone: +12897685233

Flora Pizzeria


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Flora Pizzeria (@flora.pizzeria)

Flora started out as a small shop in downtown Hamilton Ontario, making Roman-style pizza for people who enjoy this type of cuisine.

This is an excellent spot to get a fantastic pizza in a warm, friendly atmosphere! I love the quality of the ingredients and how everything is made fresh.

Their broccoli and tomato pizza is my favorite, but their margarita pizza is also really good!

Address: 4 Young St, Hamilton, ON L8N 1T9, Canada


Phone: +13653244599

La Spaghett Pasta House


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by La Spaghett (@laspaghett)

There are two things to get excited about at this amazing little bistro. First, they serve incredible homemade pasta. There are around 30 or more different toppings and sauces.

Everything ranging from a simple bolognaise to a roquefort rustico cream sauce with bacon, leeks, tomatoes, walnuts, etc.

Second, the restaurant is known for its big appetizers that take time to prepare because of their huge portions and quality. The staff is extremely friendly.

We recommend this place for anyone looking for an intimate place with great food and drinks!

Address:  970 Upper James St, Hamilton, ON L9C 3A5, Canada


Phone: +19053188211

La Piazza Allegra


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by La Piazza Allegra (@lapiazzaallegra)

The Piazza Allegra is a hidden gem in South Hamilton. Surrounded by great local eateries, this Italian restaurant fits in quite nicely.

Great Italian cuisine with a half decent wine menu of reds and whites plus cocktails.

Try to get a table by the window because it offers a taste of the social scene; nothing beats people-watching while having dinner during nice weather.

Parking is available out front but good luck getting a spot if you come on weekends.

Address: 180 James St S, Hamilton, ON L8P 4V1, Canada


Phone: +19057778970

Alfredo's Place is a family-owned and operated Hamilton restaurant serving gourmet dishes from the most authentic regions of Italy.

Alfredo's Place is a hidden gem. Fantastic euthentic Italian cuisine!! Tasted just like Nonna's cooking.

Big portions, and the customer service is outstanding!!

Address: 931 Fennell Ave E, Hamilton, ON L8V 1W9, Canada


Phone: +19053833555

Final Thoughts for the Best Italian Restaurants in Hamilton

There’s no question that Hamilton has an abundance of delicious Italian food. The city is teeming with eateries that serve the food, from well-known classics to eagerly awaited newbies.

Whether you’re searching for a casual neighborhood restaurant or an elegant fine-dining experience, the city’s abundance of options will satisfy any pallet.

Italian restaurants in Hamilton come in various styles, sizes, and price points. So naturally, the fashions also vary greatly, from traditional red sauce venues to chef-driven pizza and pasta establishments to the trendy, new Italian restaurants.

Fortunately, you can get practically anything you want in the Italian restaurants in Hamilton, both in terms of décor and cost.


  • Jess Levy

    Jess Levy is an artist, travel writer, foddie, and marketer. She loves planning local and international trips to nourish her creative soul.

Scroll to Top